Which League Table?

cables · Post by **cables** » Sun Oct 09, 2005 6:38 pm

The CL new-style table is now (Played) Pts.:

Munster (6) 23
Ulster (6) 22
Edinburgh Gunners (6) 18
Border Reivers (6) 17
Leinster (6) 17
Cardiff Blues (5) 15
Glasgow Warriors (6) 12
Llanelli Scarlets (5) 11
Dragons (5) 10
Ospreys (5) 9
Connacht (6) 5

An old style table with no free-week points and no counting a free-week as if a team had played would be:

Munster (6) 23
Edinburgh Gunners (6) 18
Ulster (5) 18
Border Reivers (5) 13
Leinster (5) 13
Llanelli Scarlets (5) 11
Cardiff Blues (4) 11
Ospreys (5) 9
Glasgow Warriors (5) 8
Dragons (4) 6
Connacht (6) 5

The old style table puts us in 3rd position 5 points off the lead but with a game in hand against the (2) teams above us. Munster have a free-week next weekend and we travel to the team just below us (in both tables).

Which table do you prefer and do you think the CL decision has fulfilled their desire to â€œaddress the imbalance in the league table caused by having an uneven number of teams in the competitionâ€? Or, has the decision just introduced confusion?

Mid-Terrace · Post by **Mid-Terrace** » Sun Oct 09, 2005 6:40 pm

I think we should be credited with a little bit of intelligence and leave it as it was! Far more realistic???

Post by **fermain** » Sun Oct 09, 2005 6:54 pm

yup, old style for me.

browner · Post by **browner** » Sun Oct 09, 2005 7:08 pm

Much prefer the old style.

pwrmoore · Post by **pwrmoore** » Sun Oct 09, 2005 7:27 pm

Can't get too worked up over this one. I never had any problems working with the old style. The new way isn't a bad idea but it only really worked as it was designed to with the pre-Powergen Cup fixture list. The welsh teams playing games out of sequence really makes the whole change of methods pointless.

Magical O' Driscoll · Post by **Magical O' Driscoll** » Sun Oct 09, 2005 8:43 pm

Old style for me.

cables · Post by **cables** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 6:30 pm

4:1 of those who replied.

A lot of opinion formers on this MB have perhaps not felt it was of much importance and that is fine.

I can now scrap an Ulternative Alster embryonic idea.

Thanks anyway it will save some work.

browner · Post by **browner** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 10:38 pm

Just added my vote Cables,will it make any difference?

cables · Post by **cables** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 10:43 pm

Yep it is now 5:1
Does that answer your question Browner?

browner · Post by **browner** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 10:46 pm

How many votes do you need before the embryo develops?

Rooster · Post by **Rooster** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 10:49 pm

I like the old one, and the West English have made a ballex of the new method anyway

cables · Post by **cables** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 11:03 pm

Think the old style one could be produced fairly readily and that it would also be in keeping with the 'Ulternative Alster' theme of this website.

e.g. the Ulternative Alster Celtic League Table
or the Ulternative Celtic League Table and perhaps the Scots and Welsh would come to 'visit' when they got to know about it.

The front page one could still be carried.

Guess I am in trouble with fermain now!

browner · Post by **browner** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 11:06 pm

What's keepin you then?

Post by **fermain** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 11:09 pm

nooo, if you click on the words in the red line on the CL table on the frontpage, it takes you to the newlook full table, week 6!! as contributed by cables, and the original kimble...thanks guys.

Were you thinking of doing something different cables?

cables · Post by **cables** » Mon Oct 10, 2005 11:23 pm

Not really, really, really fermain. I do have some grave doubts regarding the CL decision re this and I thought it would marry (Ulternative) well with this site if the same thing were produced containing all details as the one you have alerted everyone to but leaving out all elements of the free weeks and showing it as an old-style table.

Happy to suck and see feedback.

The UAFC

Which League Table?

Which table do you prefer?

Which League Table?