CIMANFOREVER wrote:Jackie Brown wrote:Ridiculous if true. Payne is a full back and Cave is a 13.
Cave may also be a very useful 12 imo.
Bottom line, we need a good back up 15, more than anything...
I'd be happy enough with Cave 12 and Payne 13, if we had a quality FB behind. Maybe Olding going forward...
Agree completely CI.
I have said for years 12 is Caves best position.
He is the defensive leader and since you defend in to out it makes sense he is inside.
He is a ball player,thinker, reads the game well and creates made for 12 but does not the hit line like Payne or Bowe can which a 13 should really do.
He hasnt got the pace of others but the closer inside the more congestion and less space there is so that of defuses the pace issue.
The pace and threat comes further outside and Cave can create the room for others to play.
It would not surprise me if he is considered for Ireland in that position and he may get a career boost similar to Wallace when he started playing there.
No problem with Jared at 13 other than that makes Gilroy 15.
Again good on the counter and under the high ball but it is an art to time and hit a line from deep like Payne and Kearney can do and Gilroy does not do that to date.
That can come with experience but he has not played there consistantly enough to get his timing.
Also we will miss Paynes unerring tactical decision making in that knowing when to run and when and where to kick.
For me our strongest back line is the same one I suggested 2 years ago with Cave 12, Bowe 13, Gilroy and AT on the wings with Windy at 15.
Dont know what this new signing is like but I can see Olding being our long term 15 as he has the skills and atributes to play there since Payne doesnt fancy it.