Marshall and Wilson cited

[Deraless]

Ref the Marshall incident -if the charge is 'reckless endangerment' shouldn't the other Scarlets player also be cited? He kicked him harder than Luke.... then again, if your own team mates could be done for 'reckless endangerment' half our squad would be cited every week....

beagle would be up on a charge of manslaughter some of his passes

[BaggyTrousers]

The Book of Roger is a geographical text written in Arabic in the 12th century.

On Britain:

As for Britain, it "is set in the Sea of Darkness. It is a considerable island, whose shape is that of the head of an ostrich, and where there are flourishing towns, high mountains, great rivers and plains. This country is most fertile; its inhabitants are brave, active and enterprising, but all is in the grip of perpetual winter."

Ah the great days of Arabic culture when there was a thirst for knowledge rather than blood.

[BaggyTrousers]

I have a horrible feeling we're going to lose both of them for this match.

Roger very clearly innocent. Case dismissed.

[Russ]

Both will be banned

[Dave]

Both will be banned

A year each.

[Russ]

Both will be banned

A year each.

No seriously

Any welshman worth his salt knows marshall booted him and Wilson punched him

[Dave]

Both will be banned

A year each.

No seriously

Any welshman worth his salt knows marshall booted him and Wilson punched him

Thugs

[Dave]

Both will be banned

A year each.

No seriously

Any welshman worth his salt knows marshall booted him and Wilson punched him

Indeed, both actions clearly premeditated and probably practiced in training to make it look innocently accidental. Both deserve flogging.

I'd rather have Liam Williams and Hartley

[pwrmoore]

Is Wilsons citing for the punch no punch.... I seen him leave an elbow in someone's face on one of Gilroys runs.

Nah it was the so called punch the ref said was ok, it is in the video link.

On Marshalls one it looks like Luke hit him and then a Scarlets player hit him but the real bang to the head was when he hit the ground in the tackle.

I agree rooster - the scarlets player coming in after Luke certainly seems to do more damage than Luke did. I'd hope, given that his own player also failed to avoid contact, luke will be cleared of this. But he probably won't.

[Snipe Watson]

Are the hearings today?

[Russ]

Are the hearings today?

It's 4 march 1972 according to wales

[Rooster]

Is Wilsons citing for the punch no punch.... I seen him leave an elbow in someone's face on one of Gilroys runs.

Nah it was the so called punch the ref said was ok, it is in the video link.

On Marshalls one it looks like Luke hit him and then a Scarlets player hit him but the real bang to the head was when he hit the ground in the tackle.

I agree rooster - the scarlets player coming in after Luke certainly seems to do more damage than Luke did. I'd hope, given that his own player also failed to avoid contact, luke will be cleared of this. But he probably won't.

It actually looked like the second thump was harder and the one that did the damage and made the tweety birds appear

[ScarletsMun]

Just to put things into perspective (on this lovely thread which you all must be so proud of), Nick Williams' illegal ruck clearout has ended Aaron Shingler's season.

[big mervyn]

Just to put things into perspective (on this lovely thread which you all must be so proud of), Nick Williams' illegal ruck clearout has ended Aaron Shingler's season.

The commentators on S4C didn't think it was illegal.

[Cornerfleg]

I'd like to put things into perspective as well ... if I may ... ahem ....