Try/No Try?

[BR]

It was Humph's try that I believe the TJ got wrong, as did many of the Ulster supporters around me (Aquinas end terrace) - didn't stop us shouting like, but if I'm to be honest, it looked like a 22 to me. And rather than talking crp Brian, I was trying to clarify what other people had seen for the knock-on. It looked good to me, but I did not have the best view, hence the question.

[Setanta]

Doesn't seem to be conclusive either way - witness Castres try today against Gloucester - looked good but the referee was behind and so went upstairs; camera angle showed ball was dropped before the line quite clearly but the TMO gave the try anyway!!

[backawaygoonahead]

There is also the point that the photo could prove Danielli put is had on the ball after he knocked it on, think about it photos do lie at times.

Or so David Attoub said anyway

[brianc]

And rather than talking crp Brian, I was trying to clarify what other people had seen for the knock-on. It looked good to me, but I did not have the best view, hence the question.

Oops, my post didn't really mean to say that . Was just coincidental that I was responding to Rob6 so soon after speaking with Diack, and obviously didn't word it very well!!

[BR]

And rather than talking crp Brian, I was trying to clarify what other people had seen for the knock-on. It looked good to me, but I did not have the best view, hence the question.

Oops, my post didn't really mean to say that . Was just coincidental that I was responding to Rob6 so soon after speaking with Diack, and obviously didn't word it very well!!

Ahh... sure we can call it quits on the other 99% of my posts where I am talking crp!

[Rob6]

Amazing the amount of cr*p people will tell you Rob6. Was talking to Robbie after the game & he is already getting some stick about dropping the ball over the line. Said he wasn't looking forward to seeing the video

Fair enough Brianc.... I was only posting what I was told.... I was down at the half way line on the terrace and couldn't see what was happening!!!

[Yoda]

It was Humph's try that I believe the TJ got wrong, as did many of the Ulster supporters around me (Aquinas end terrace) - didn't stop us shouting like, but if I'm to be honest, it looked like a 22 to me. And rather than talking crp Brian, I was trying to clarify what other people had seen for the knock-on. It looked good to me, but I did not have the best view, hence the question.

Looks ok to me based on the one camera angle available. Re Danielli's - photo looks conclusive but how the touch judge gave it from the angle he saw it from I'll never know!

[Alister Scott]

read the papers

look at the websites

check the scoreboard

they WERE tries (except Robbie's, obviously)

[Digifriendly]

Doesn't seem to be conclusive either way - witness Castres try today against Gloucester - looked good but the referee was behind and so went upstairs; camera angle showed ball was dropped before the line quite clearly but the TMO gave the try anyway!!

Castres played Northampton on Friday and Gloucester were playing Agen in the Amlin Cup not the HC.

[Billyboy]

TRY
http://www.dicksondigital.com/index.cgi ... 10_164.jpg

[BR]

TRY
http://www.dicksondigital.com/index.cgi ... 10_164.jpg

Didn't have many doubts about Danielli's. Do you have any pics of iHumph's though?

[Billyboy]

NO TRY
http://dicksondigital.com/index.cgi?por ... 10_219.jpg

Don't see any pics around for the Humph try but it looked ok to me.

[Rooster]

The 2 with a doubt were ihumph's and Robbies, one given one disallowed.